i voted other b/c i like both.. there is just no clear answer to this question. if a game has amazing graphics but it sucks a**, then why would i want to play it? but i do love graphics a whole let, hence me having a 7800gt. but usually any game with sweet graphics is a good game anyways, such as oblivion! gameplay of coarse is important but i dont want to play a game that is like 10yrs old and looks really crappy. but thats for computers. now for consoles vs computers... a computer beats a console in every aspect but price. graphics are 10x better on a comp no matter what system your talking about, and to me the gameplay is alot better b/c i can use a mouse/keyboard. a controller just doesnt have enough buttons. now ive beaten both oblivion and hitman blood money on my computer, both of those games have amazing gameplay and graphics on the computer, ive never played them on a console so i cant tell. but HDR with oblivion is just f***ing AMAZING!!!