Technically, newer (faster) CD drives would be louder, but not at the levels you are talking about. CD drives have a pretty lame lifespan as they often move into the "loud" or "won't eject without a paperclip" phase fairly quickly. In fact the CD drive in my PC needs the paperclip to eject. Fortunately they are fairly cheap (new) enough to not worry about spending money on a new one. The only thing is that most companies are phasing out PATA which could become a problem for people with older hardware. In my experience, Lite-On drives seem to have the shortest lifespan. Usually, once the drive won't eject with the button it is only a matter of time before it goes completely.