Jump to content

Hard Drive Manufacturers: The Definitive Thread

jcarle

By jcarle
in The Poll Center

 Share

Which hard drive manufacturer do you...  

44 members have voted

  1. 1. trust the MOST?

    • Maxtor
      3
    • Seagate
      21
    • Western Digital
      20

  2. 2. trust the LEAST?

    • Maxtor
      21
    • Seagate
      8
    • Western Digital
      15

Recommended Posts

jcarle

jcarle

Posted
Posted

Let's make this the definitive thread on hard drives. Let's debate, argue and exchange all our personal experiences, thoughts and opinions regarding current manufacturers of hard drives.

I kept the poll down to the top 3 hard drive manufacturers because those are the ones that are the most significant in the current market.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

jcarle

jcarle

Posted
  • Author
Posted

I got scared off of Seagate when I had to RMA a batch of about 30 different 40GB and 60GB hard drives... mind you, that was out of a lot of several hundred, but still... Western Digital is the only company I've never sent an RMA to. I'm perplexed on how people have come to distrust a company I trust so much, or the inverse, how people can trust so much a company I distrust so much. I guess it's like all things in life, personal experiences make it hard to change your mind.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
CoffeeFiend

CoffeeFiend

Posted
Posted
I got scared off of Seagate when I had to RMA a batch of about 30 different 40GB and 60GB hard drives... mind you, that was out of a lot of several hundred, but still... Western Digital is the only company I've never sent an RMA to. I'm perplexed on how people have come to distrust a company I trust so much, or the inverse, how people can trust so much a company I distrust so much. I guess it's like all things in life, personal experiences make it hard to change your mind.

I guess it comes from mixed experiences. I've never had to RMA a single seagate drive EVER. And very few from maxtor/samsung/thosiba/hitachi/etc. Then there's the obvious ones I've seen LOTS of - not really the more known bad series like 5 platter "deathstars" - but things like the notoriously bad batches of fujitsus that resulted in a class action lawsuit (we're measuring by the full triwall of bad HDs here). And besides those bad batches, the only brand we've had significant problems with is WD. Be it by total # of bad drives or percentage (bad/total) or anything, they lose on all metrics. It's bad enough that we ensure that the new PCs we buy don't have WD drives in 'em (and we buy them by the pallet). So yeah, I don't trust my data to any WD drive, and will take ANYTHING over it. After seeing so many bad WDs, there's no way I could possibly trust them (it's not just one or two bad series like the fujitsu or "deathstars"). It's certainly not a few ppl on an forum that have seen 2 bad maxtors in a lifetime (hence they must suck!) or such that will make me change my mind. From anecdotal evidence, extremely low sample sizes making these statistically meaningless, when it's not actually the user's fault the drive died (cooling problem or such), and plain luck/bad luck (on a low scale), it's hard to attach much relevance to these.

As for the best/most trusted brand, I picked seagate for lack of more comprehensive options ("almost anything"), but it's a good drive, good value, good performance and all.

As for the totally untrusted one, I guess everybody can tell...

Link to comment
Share on other sites
jcarle

jcarle

Posted
  • Author
Posted

@crahak:

You don't happen to remember which drives you had problems with? 120GB? 2MB cache? I do remember there being issues with the 120GB and unrelatedly that 2MB drives were rebranded maxtors...

Link to comment
Share on other sites
LLXX

LLXX

Posted
Posted
@crahak:

You don't happen to remember which drives you had problems with? 120GB? 2MB cache? I do remember there being issues with the 120GB and unrelatedly that 2MB drives were rebranded maxtors...

I think those were the BBs.

I have a pair of WD1200JB and they've been fine for 2 years of continuous operation.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
jcarle

jcarle

Posted
  • Author
Posted

@crahak:

You don't happen to remember which drives you had problems with? 120GB? 2MB cache? I do remember there being issues with the 120GB and unrelatedly that 2MB drives were rebranded maxtors...

I think those were the BBs.

I have a pair of WD1200JB and they've been fine for 2 years of continuous operation.

Yea, BB would be a 2MB cache drive. :} Unfortunately, it seems that the 2MB drives were not really up to be the most reliable drives. Personally, I've only ever bought 8MB drives for that reason.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
mad_dog369

mad_dog369

Posted
Posted (edited)

Some time in 2004 I got my hands on a office pc specs were, 128 ram, 1.2 GHz Intel, 20gig hdd, don’t remember the mother bored( the mother board had died)

the Hdd had no branding on it and the serial code is just zero's and it's really heavy and feels solid, no hdd programmes can get a clear name from the hdd and it has never had data corruption nor loss and has never crashed oh yeah did I mention it is pretty dam quiet even when scanning with an a.v, it sits in my old pc in my room that I use every now and then.

P.s had bad luck with WD and only ever owned 1 Maxtor that also died within the first month owning it.

Edited by mad_dog369
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.


×
×
  • Create New...