resq4u Posted February 25, 2008 Posted February 25, 2008 I have a Geniune copy of Vista Ultimate. And for long I was waiting for PreIntegrated Vista SP1 from microsoft official Web site (MSDN and Connect). But it seems that P2P has yet again defeated the official relese dates. I recently downloaded "6001.18000.080118-1840_x86fre_Client_en-us-FRMCFRE_EN_DVD.iso" from torrent network (CRC: 0xCE4CB528, MD5: b09267740ddd1a08d80b04ec6bbc232a). Is it legal to use it instead of using my Non-SP1 vista copy? And whether its an actual Vista SP1 or not?
oskingen Posted February 25, 2008 Posted February 25, 2008 (edited) I have a Geniune copy of Vista Ultimate. And for long I was waiting for PreIntegrated Vista SP1 from microsoft official Web site (MSDN and Connect). But it seems that P2P has yet again defeated the official relese dates. I recently downloaded "6001.18000.080118-1840_x86fre_Client_en-us-FRMCFRE_EN_DVD.iso" from torrent network (CRC: 0xCE4CB528, MD5: b09267740ddd1a08d80b04ec6bbc232a). Is it legal to use it instead of using my Non-SP1 vista copy? And whether its an actual Vista SP1 or not?So what do you think ? Is it legal or not ? Edited February 25, 2008 by hannubys
Idontwantspam Posted February 25, 2008 Posted February 25, 2008 If you have to ask.... Now what do you think?
PC_LOAD_LETTER Posted February 25, 2008 Posted February 25, 2008 Really the question you should be asking is not 'Is this legal?' but 'Is this a good idea?'
resq4u Posted February 25, 2008 Author Posted February 25, 2008 Really the question you should be asking is not 'Is this legal?' but 'Is this a good idea?'"Good Idea"....what..getting it through torrent??...or something else??!!
newsposter Posted February 25, 2008 Posted February 25, 2008 why would you assume that an OS load obtained from anyone except the original maker (MSFT, etc) is both legit and not pre-loaded with spyware, etc?
resq4u Posted February 25, 2008 Author Posted February 25, 2008 why would you assume that an OS load obtained from anyone except the original maker (MSFT, etc) is both legit and not pre-loaded with spyware, etc?That's why I've given the CRC & MD5 Hashes of that ISO and want someone to confirm that its the orignal one; as I'm in no mood of downloading ~3GB of data again. If the hashes doesn't match, then its crap.
Legolash2o Posted February 25, 2008 Posted February 25, 2008 (edited) It IS illegal.The situation infuriated some users after they found pirates could download illegal copies of SP1 RTM from BitTorrent sites while developers were locked out by Microsoft.As predicted, pirate copies of Vista SP1 and Windows Server 2008 are already available from Bittorrent websites, weeks before consumers can get them legally, showing once again just how efficient hackers and decentralised networks really are at providing and distributing illegal stuff.And the winner goes too....*drum role please* (bored)Want to download a copy of Vista SP1 or Windows Server 2008 now that they’ve gone to RTM? Sadly, the only way to do it is by breaking the law, with both programs having already made their way onto the world’s bittorrent networks.There's your answer -Lego---------------------------Quote Links-----------------------------------First quote - http://www.computerworld.com/action/articl...p;intsrc=kc_topSecond and Third quote - http://www.itwire.com/content/view/16524/1105/--------------------------------------------------------------------------- Edited February 25, 2008 by LegoLiam™
resq4u Posted February 25, 2008 Author Posted February 25, 2008 Well....that more-or-less answers my both queries....the reason was that yesterday I tested it on VirtualPC after Vliting it...and faced a problem in "Switching window's features On/Off"...I was unable to change any setting in it. Same removal settings worked flawlessly in Plain Vista.But anyway, I think Now is not the right time for asking SP1 related problems...or is it??Thanks
Legolash2o Posted February 25, 2008 Posted February 25, 2008 (edited) Yes you can report sp1 preintegrated bugs, preferably in a new topic as this doesn't have the title to match. Edited February 25, 2008 by LegoLiam™
Camarade_Tux Posted February 25, 2008 Posted February 25, 2008 It IS illegal.It is absolutely nothing.Unless you are referring to some country legislation, you can't state anything.Consider this example : you've bought a CD (music, OS, anything), you forgot it near the window and the CD got damaged by the sun. What happens if you download a replacement copy ?In France, it has recently been declared illegal because all copyrighted download has been (before only sending data was illegal) and the interesting point is you will be directly fined, there will be no judgement and imho this is because a court would not rule you are guilty.It is also important to know that EULA (including some Microsoft's) are not applicable in some countries as they are against the law.If you want a definitive answer, you have to check three things : your country law, what is called "jurisprudence" here is France (previous rulings) and the software's EULAs.As such you have to know whether such downloads are legal or not. But I doubt anybody would bother you with this as unofficial SP downloads incur absolutely no loss to microsoft.
nuhi Posted February 25, 2008 Posted February 25, 2008 I would say that any third party Windows ISO download is illegal.To be on the safe side simply make your own SP1 ISO, it is completely functional as the real thing.Guide here:http://www.winbeta.org/comments.php?catid=1&id=9536
hclarkjr Posted February 25, 2008 Posted February 25, 2008 my feelings on this subject are this - you paid for your copy of vista with its legit key. so if micosoft will not send you a DVD with service pack 1 integrated, i went to micosoft forums and asked this very question and was told that no microsoft will not do that, then i feel that if you can get an image which is untouched and by that i mean cracked or loaded with spyware and viruses then it is within your right to do so. what are they going to do to you? you did not pirate anything and you have the COA and a legit key.
Tarun Posted February 25, 2008 Posted February 25, 2008 Unless you directly download it from Microsoft or an authorized Microsoft source, it is illegal.[ Closed ]
Recommended Posts