Andalu

Do you have used the Dibya PAE patch in your test? What tool do you use to initialize a 6TB disk in MBR that has only one partition? I know of only the WD Quick Formatter that permits such a thing (and allows you to use a 2TB+ HDD in XP).

You should find a board that can allow you to replicate that situation that worked for you. A few months ago I had posted here: https://msfn.org/board/topic/181911-read-gpt-hard-disk-on-windows-xp/page/9/#findComment-1259400 It should also work by using the normal eSata cable if your caddy has its own power supply, but having never tried it I cannot be sure. This is another choice (already posted here https://msfn.org/board/topic/181911-read-gpt-hard-disk-on-windows-xp/page/28/#findComment-1277039): In either case, it is mandatory that the PCI-Ex card of your preference must have the button to select either "No Boot" or "IDE Boot" mode, otherwise it is seen as AHCI and you cannot use the Paragon driver to be able to get the GPT disks to work. Once again, I cannot guarantee that the cards can work in your system as well. I tested all of them with good results....until now .

The driver that can be installed for that card is asahci32.sys, which allows recognition of GPT disks only when the Win2003 disk.sys and partmgr.sys drivers are present in the system. Unfortunately, those versions of the Win2003 drivers result in data corruption as much as the data written to the disk exceeds 2TB, even if no PAE patch has been installed.

I can't suggest a card and give you the assurance that it will work on your system as well. As I wrote in a previous post, there are other aspects to keep in mind that can determine failure on one system and success on another. Among these, the characteristics of a disk are of essential importance. In your case, you should specify the type of connection you intend to use for your GPT disk: do you want to connect it directly to the motherboard or plug it into an enclosure? I know that the ideal solution would be to be able to use it in either case but it may be more difficult to achieve. Then, in the case of the external box, what kind of connection would you like to use, USB or eSata? If I'm not mistaken, you wrote that by connecting it directly to the sata port on the motherboard the drive is properly recognized with the Paragon driver, so I think your system is configured in IDE mode. Have you tried writing data to it by exceeding the 2TB limit yet verifying that data corruption does not occur? Without having this information, it is a bit complicated to make suggestions.

I have a card very similar to this one. I tried it again a few days ago and with GPT disks there is data corruption. I hope I am wrong and that it will work for you.

I also just tried this PCI-Express to eSATA card with ASM1061 chipset: and also in this case, both 4TB and 16TB GPT disks connected directly to the eSata ports of the same card seem to work smoothly thanks to the Paragon driver v10.1.25.779.

Thanks to the Paragon GPT Loader driver v10.1.25.779, HDDs initialized as GPT can be recognized correctly in XP as data disks, but only if the motherboard bios has the option to enable IDE mode. In AHCI mode, GPT HDDs are not recognized even with the Paragon driver. The following way could allow XP to recognize GPT partitions using the GPT_Loader driver even on a system configured in AHCI mode. It is required to use a PCI-Express to Sata card with the Asmedia ASM1061 chipset which must have a selector button that allows you to choose between three positions: "AHCI Boot", "no Boot" and "IDE Boot". I have tested these two ASM1061 cards: this is the back of one of them (the other contains the same info on the rear): After selecting "No Boot" and plugging the card into the PCI-Express slot, on the boot XP recognizes it immediately as "Standard Dual Channel PCI IDE controller" with "Primary and Secondary IDE Channels". No Asmedia driver required. Here is how the GPT disk just plugged to the Asmedia card is recognized by XP before installing the Paragon driver: I chose to install the Paragon driver using a different gpt_loader.inf than the original one. Thanks to the two users "DCT" and "satmonk" with posts #30 dated 10/18/2015 at 14:31 and #33 dated 02/2/2017 at 21:08 at link: http://hardwarefetish.com/524-paragon-gpt_loadersys-bsod-analysis-and-fix it is possible to create a special .inf file that can be used to install the Paragon GPT Loader v10.1.25.779 only for the GPT disk just connected to the PCI to Sata card. I made some changes in the gpt_loader.inf file mentioned in the previous link: under the section [Strings] where I replaced Paragon = "Paragon and Co BIG HDD" with Paragon = "Paragon Software Group" and DiskId1 = "3Tb HDD disk driver" with DiskId1 = "GUID Partition table Driver Disc" The installation procedure of the Paragon driver must be executed by selecting the GPT disk -> update driver -> (advanced) -> don't search -> have disk -> browse to the path containing the required files (gpt_loader.sys, gpt_loader.cat and the special gpt_loader.inf file created above). You will get this warning: and of course you need to choose "Yes" to install the driver. The system reboot is prompted by the system, and the azure screen asking to chkdsk the GPT disk will probably appear during the next boot. I avoided doing this the first time and did it in another test, in both cases I found no problems with proper HDD operation. The driver installation procedure described above is needed for each new GPT disk connected to the asmedia card. Here is how the disk is now detected: Below is a 16TB GPT disk connected to the same asmedia board (although it has 4 sata ports only two disks connected at the same time seem to be working): In XP, I wrote many GB to the 4TB disk and then tested all the files, which were undamaged. I ran chkdsk in both XP and Win10 for both GPT disks and no error was detected. Switching disks between these O.S. also worked well. I also got the same results by selecting "IDE Boot" mode on the same Asmedia PCI-Ex cards. Some notes: - in my test I used disk.sys v5.1.2600.5597 and partmgr.sys v5.1.2600.5512. The versions from win2003 of these drivers can result in data corruption; - one or two time I encountered the error code 39 during the installation of the GPT Loader for disks just connected to the card. A restart is enough to overcome that error and then the disk is correctly detected as GPT; - due to possible incompatibility with the Paragon driver, the WinXPPAE patch to recognize the total RAM installed in the system or only 4GB can't be used, otherwise data corruption occurs; - after the first chkdsk of the 4TB disk executed in Win10, the next time it was connected to XP it was necessary to re-install the Paragon driver, which then did not happen for the 16TB disk and other GPT disks; - I tried five GPT disks connected to the asmedia board and all has been recognized correctly but I cannot be sure that this is the case for any GPT disk; - the disks tested shutdown correctly when removed via the HotSwap! tool. Please consider that I have not had the opportunity to examine in depth all aspects of using GPT disks in the above mode due to lack of time (and later will probably have even less). Those interested in trying it out will have to be aware of the risks associated with possible data loss, so it is better not to use disks with important data. What I have reported above is what has occurred on my system. Proper working on other systems is not guaranteed, because other things may lead to a different result from the one I got. Anyone who would like to apply the above method does so at his own risk.

The WinXPPAE patch v3.5 enables recognition of the full amount of RAM installed in the system with the "/M:ALL" option or 4GB with the "/M:4GB" option. It has always worked without any problems. It is a pity there are problems with the Paragon driver. I had tried the PAE addon by Dibya in the past but it had never worked on my systems. When I have some time on my hands I will try it again following your instructions, thanks

I discovered that the file corruption that occurs in XP when exceeding the 2TB limit depends on the WinXPPAE patch (in my system it had been enabled with the /All option). Without installing that patch, all files that are copied exceeding the 2TB limit remain uncorrupted even after rebooting the system. I need to check if the PAE patch can be enabled at least with the /4GB option without data corruption problems. Finally, thanks to @Cixert who pointed out the correct version of the Paragon driver, we can say that GPT disks can also be used in XP. (although unfortunately only in IDE mode )

I just did another test by connecting a Seagate 16TB disk containing data that was written only in Win10 and once again some video files are found to be corrupted:

I re-tested the GPT_Loader driver in XP and got the same results as before. This time I also used the disk.sys driver v5.1.2600.5512, verified in Win10 that the disk contained no errors, and executed the defrag. The disk has no errors: I did not follow up writing data to the disk in XP with the H2testw tool as I prefer to use explorer.exe which is the application that is most used in XP for copy operations. Below is the disk and driver versions installed in XP before proceeding to copy a single .mp4 file of about 300MB. All the files already on the disk were checked with MediaInfo and found to be undamaged: After completing the copy, MediaInfo shows the correct data for the video file. But after restarting the system, the .mp4 file turns out to be corrupt and MediaInfo does not show any data about the video:

Yes, the cluster size of the test disk is 4KB.

I do not know the version uploaded on Mediafire. I got that version of the Paragon driver from an earlier XP release from Ramsey. The .sys file has MD5: 75238FAEB1B5B13E6EB577B79DAAD3D9. As reported, even with that version, the data still gets corrupted.

Some time ago I did the test with the Paragon driver v11.0.0.175 without success: https://msfn.org/board/topic/181911-read-gpt-hard-disk-on-windows-xp/page/23/#findComment-1263977 so I wanted to try version 10.1.25.779 which @Cixert found to work properly even when exceeding the limit of 2TB of data copied to the disk.

All my disks have 4096 bytes per physical sector so I have no possibility to make tests with a disk that has 512 bytes per physical sector. My drive is also connected directly to the motherboard via sata port and the bios is configured in IDE Mode. In my current test and the previous one with gpt_loader v11.0.0.175 I simply copied the large part of the files in Win10 and the next one in XP. In both cases I used explorer.exe via classic copy and paste. These are many video files contained in various folders. To verify that the copied files are uncorrupted, I use the MediaInfo utility. If any files have problems, it shows a window without the video data. Really simple and quick. That is why I use video files. Once I have identified the corrupt ones, I do a comparison between the two SHA-1 codes, the one from the original file and the one that became corrupted. In no case did MediaInfo show incorrect results.

@Cixert Hi, thanks for your tests. Unfortunately, even with the GPT Loader v8.0.1.0 from Paragon Partition Manager 15 Professional x86 v10.1.25.779, data corruption occurred in my system configured in IDE mode when the files copied exceeding the 2TB limit. During the installation of Paragon Partition Manager 15 Professional, only the GPT_Loader driver was installed. I used a Seagate ST4000LM024 4TB disk initialized as GPT in Win10 with one NTFS partition only and with the files copied previously in Win10 for a total of 1,933,348,982,784 bytes. Before testing, I checked the integrity of all files. Disk.sys and Partmgr.sys installed are versions of XP, v5.1.2600.5597 and v5.1.2600.5512, respectively. I started copying the files in XP until to reach 2,199,981,613,056 bytes. Checking file integrity: no problems detected. When 12 more files for a total of 13,656,097,175 bytes were copied to the disk, I noticed that one has become corrupted. After a reboot, all 12 files are now corrupted. As a final note, during the first stage of copying files in XP, the bsod 0x00000024 occurred for gpt_lo~1.sys

@ED_Sln comctl32.dll v6.0.3790.16391 does its job, thank you I noticed that different versions of the comctl32.dll are loaded for MPC-HC v1.7.13.112 if you use the manifest files or if you run the modified mpc-hc.exe file. With the modified mpc-hc.exe file, the library comctl32.dll loaded is the version 6.0.2600.7660 contained in the directory c:\windows\winsxs\x86_microsoft.windows.common-controls_6595b64144ccf1df_6.0.2600.7660_x-ww_936580bb and in this case both the control buttons and the 'Help' tab work correctly. When manifest files are used, the loaded comctl32.dll library is the one contained in the C:\WINDOWS\system32 directory and in this case the control buttons are not correctly displayed and the 'Help' tab does not work. The strange thing is that if comctl32.dll v6.0.2600.7660 is copied to the 'Share' folder (and consequently the share.manifest file is edited) the control buttons are correctly displayed while the 'Help' tab does not work. Therefore in case of using the manifest files the fully working version of the comctl32.dll library for MPC-HC v1.7.13.112 is the one uploaded by @ED_Sln P.S.: I did not use a skin other than the default one

@Zorba the Geek Using the two manifest files as you described, MPC-HC v1.7.13.112 does not start at all here. The strange thing is that it starts when launched under Sandboxie. Instead, with the method suggested by @ED_Sln MPC-HC v1.7.13.112 starts normally: I have not had a chance to test it thoroughly, however, as can be seen in the image above, for example, the keys are not displayed correctly. Also, clicking on the 'Help' tab and then on 'About' does not display any screen. The same happens under Sandboxie. Therefore, there seems to be some problem when manifest files are used. I would like to be able to find a way to use the manifest files also for codecs and libraries contained in the "LAVFilters" folder of MPC-HC. But I don't know if it is possible to do this.

Are you maybe using a PS/2 keyboard? I had the same problem with another asrock board: "the acpi V4 also works on Asus Prime B250 and Asrock B250M Pro4 (on the lattest the restart still doesn't work with a PS/2 keyboard connected" https://msfn.org/board/topic/183464-compiling-acpi-v20-driver-for-windows-xp-sp3-and-windows-2003-sp2-x32x64/page/34/#findComment-1217657

I did not use the Manifest files method, but modified the files with a hex editor to allow loading of the OCA libraries v3.0.5 that I placed in the program folder. This way MPC-HC v1.7.13.112 starts normally: The program failed to start with the same kernel32.dll v6.0.6000.16386 reported in your previous post.

Thanks for the suggestion, but splitting a disk into multiple partitions is not my goal. I would like to use a single partition. I really can't see my 16TB disk divided into 8 partitions. Also, since the Paragon GPT Loader driver is supposed to work only by enabling IDE mode, which is no longer provided in modern systems, I don't think it's worth spending any more time on it.

Yes, I used those two drivers from Win2003

I have done a test to check the behavior of the Paragon GPT Loader driver with the 2TB limit in an XP system configured in IDE mode. After formatting my 4TB Seagate ST4000LM024 GPT disk in Win10, I started to fill it always in Win10 by copying in a progressive way the files numbered from 01 to 432 until to reach 2,194,897,825,792 bytes (at the end of the copy I made sure that all the files were uncorrupted): After connecting the disk to the XP system with Paragon GPT Loader installed, I first verified again that all files were not corrupted and then copied a single file to the disk reaching a total of 2,199,889,600,512 bytes: Checking once again the integrity of all files, I noticed that the first file copied a few days earlier (the one marked with the number 01) was now corrupt while all the others were intact. But on the next system reboot, here is what happened: The problem encountered is almost the same as the one I detected using the asmedia asahci32.sys driver in a system configured in SATA/AHCI mode. The difference, which is no insignificant, is that at least with the asmedia driver, by following the identical procedure above, the drive was still accessible in XP and other files were still correctly available although the 2,199,023,255,552 bytes limit was exceeded. At this point, I also have serious doubts whether the GPT Loader can effectively work on 3TB GPT disks. It certainly does not work on 4TB GPT disks.

@roytam1 None of the storahci.sys drivers known to work in XP allow recognition of GPT disks. Tried after installing the GPT_Loader with both storport.sys from Win7 (disk not even listed in Device Manager) and storport from Win8 (disk listed in Device Manager but no volume detected). Same behavior even without installing the Paragon driver.

There are versions ported from Win8 (storahci.sys v6.2.9200.16384 and storahci.sys v6.2.9200.20652) but I actually don't remember testing them with the GPT Loader. I will give them a try.