You shouldn't create another thread just because you don't agree with what Martin L did. You should PM him, and explain why you don't think he took right choice. (Wich is also on the rules) I'm sure he respects other's opinions as much as you do, however, the way they were presented was not the best. And that's why the thread was closed. I don't think you should be judging what he did, afterall he is (aswell as the rest of the team) for you (and all the other members). If he decided to close the thread, it's because it was the right thing to do (I would have done the same).