Two Favorites/Bookmarks icons, opinions requested

[coyotewrw]

Hi all,

There's the IE star, the Apple heart and the Firefok book, but I wanted something unique since I'm taking the time to totally reshack my system.

What I've decided to use is the asterisk (*). I've created two designs, one rounded and the other squared. I like them both, but what do you think? Rounded? Squared? Neither (hope not!)?

Thanks for taking the time to give me some input.

[mazin]

I vote rounded. I wouldn't prefere any of them, though.

I'd like a star inside a circle. That's actually how my icon looks like.