Jump to content
Strawberry Orange Banana Lime Leaf Slate Sky Blueberry Grape Watermelon Chocolate Marble
Strawberry Orange Banana Lime Leaf Slate Sky Blueberry Grape Watermelon Chocolate Marble

MSFN is made available via donations, subscriptions and advertising revenue. The use of ad-blocking software hurts the site. Please disable ad-blocking software or set an exception for MSFN. Alternatively, register and become a site sponsor/subscriber and ads will be disabled automatically. 


R4D3

Windows 10 Final Release R4D3´s Feedback and Bug Report

Recommended Posts

This is my Second bigger Feedback, it´s just about the most worse things I can't stand off ! I will post it later with the built-in Feedback App)

Bugs that are still existing and I already Tested, like the most worse bit BMP Codec Bug ! Are reposted here ! 

 

if you like to read about my Wishes, and some of my already found Bugs (I did not test all off them for this Report) you have to visit:


 

My Firewall Rules Set (unperfect, unfinished) can be found here:


 

 

Feedback:

 

1) BUG: 32 Bit BMP Codec

It is Still Broken (Preview, Photos and Paint does strange things with some Color channels on 32bit Bitmaps...)

 

 

2) BUG: Standard Scheduled Tasks destroys Power Saving !

One ore more of the preconfigurated Tasks (why there are so many of them - its like a Overkill) destroys Energy Saving modes like Standby !

That means: My Laptop start Up from Sleep by itself and do things (I don't know) by itself...

 

LISTEN Microsoft: IF I SEND MY LAPTOP TO SLEEP, IT HAS TO SLEEP, NOT TO WAKEUP AND DO STUFF I DON'T KNOW, BY ITSELF ! (If I decide to add a Schedulerjob, it would run in Idle-Mode, before Standby !)

 

Solution: I removed all of the endless annoying Preconfigurated Tasklist on Scheduler, that wasn't blocked (yes some of them are blocked... - why ?)

I know that I possibly break something I maybe don't know by that - but it was the only functional Solution to get a nice and smart Powersaving System - works perfect after !)

 

 

3) Energy Saving Profiles are Inefficient !

A) If my Laptop runs Battery, I prefer to use all Possible Saving Options that are Possible - no matter which Profile is active (Solution: Manual Change on all Profiles)

B) Why the CPU Minimum Usage is Set to 5% in Minimal and Balanced Mode ? This stops the CPU going into Idle Mode and Throttledown, this costs unneeded Energy, that I have to pay for ! (Solution: Manual Change to 0% on all Profiles)

C) On High Performance The Minimum CPU Usage is Set to 100% ??? - Are you Kidding me ? Even on that Scenario my CPU like to be able to change into Idle Mode ! (Solution: See Above)

D) Why the Standard Time for Harddrives is 20min on Every Profile, when I use a SSD ? A SSD don't need time for Start Spinning like a normal Harddrive, what means, there is no Reason, to let it Run Up to 20mins if it has nothing to do (Yes with normal Harddrives it makes some sense to let them spin longer, cause it needs some seconds to respin after a SpinOff) (Solution: Manual Change to 1min on all Profiles)

 

LISTEN: USERS DON'T LIKE TO CHANGE THEIR ENERGYPROFILE 1000 TIMES OVER A DAY ! A CPU THROTTLEDOWN (CPU Reduces MHZ by Reducing the Power on IDLE MODE) MUST BE POSSIBLE EVERY TIME, ON EVERY PROFILE !!! & SSD´s ARE NON SPINNING DEVICES !

 

 

4) USB Harddrives still Spinning after a Secure Disconnect !

I know, that a secure disconnect normally is only needed if the Drive using Cached Smartdrive Techniques to be Faster (which must be toggled on for usage manual by the user)

But, cause I really don't like, to plug out cables on spinning USB Harddrives, I would prefer that Secure Disconnect sends a SPIN OFF Signal to the USB Device too...

 

LISTEN: If you don't like to add a SpinOFF Command to the Secure Disconnection, please give me back the "Park Command" from MS-DOS 5.0 !!! 

 

 

5) Windows Firewall - All Doors Open, no Outbound Dialog, if I Close them !

A) BUG 1: The UI-BUG (UI Restarts if I Copy and Paste Names on the Advanced Firewall Rules Config) is annoying !

B) BUG 2: At some Points Envorinment Varibales (used Automatic when adding an .exe File that lays as example on the User Profile) could not be readed

C) THE Standard Rules Set (Every Outbound is allowed by Standard, is the biggest security whole ever !) I like to be ASKED if a Prog like to do a Call Out, cause it is my own **** Privatsphere !

Example: A Software Developer doesn't need to Know, how often a Day, Week or Month, and on which Times Exactly I start his Program ! (if he like to know, I only tell him, if he pay me for that information !)

Its even a Security Risk, cause many Bloat and Spyware will download their s*** automatically by their Installers, and since most Software are using WEB-Installers instead of a Full OffLine Version, its getting worse)

 

But: IF I Change the Standard Rules to: Everything is Forbidden to Callout since there is no Rule - Windows Firewall don't ask my if I like to allow a Callout for Edgebrowser, Windows Update, etc... - What means that I have to make manual Rules for every Software but I wasn't able to make a Allow Rule for WindowsUpdate, what means that I have to Change my whole Rules Set back to Standard, every time I like to do Updates ! GRRRRRR !!!

 

 

6) Stop Software Hijacking my Standard Browser

Example: I install a Software, and it Starts my Browser and Loading its website by itself - I know, that I can prevent that, by Editing the Registry and put out, the Standardbrowser entry's, - but I would prefer a dialog, that asks me, if I like to allow a software, to Hijack my Browser ! (Don't like to end up on Captured Sites, that I don't click by myself ! - Don't tell me Websites can't be captured !)

 

 

7) The Search is slow and Sucks

I like the Fast and practical Search on Windows XP, where I was able to Decide if I search a String inside Files, or Files by itself...

- If I search a file with Standard Options as example for Shell32.dll - it doesn't find it... - if I change some Options its able to find it, but it needs to much time - compared to Windows XP Search, or the Software: "Agent Ransack"

 

 

8) Desktop.ini - is going worse !

Principial I like to see all hidden and System Files, and if I do so, I see the Desktop.ini (that I used in Windows XP, to force FolderBackgrounds, Foldercolor and ...) is part of the Translation Options, - and if I delete them, my Localized Shortcuts are Named in English... - Did you really need a Desktop.ini, that links to a Place in the Registry to localize my Shortcutnames ?

 

 

9) Please, LET ME Remove all Following Apps and Features, without any Problems... (i will try it again and again, cause i need to...)

 

Unneeded Ballast, cause I am using HomePremium:

- Business Edition Packages

- Education Editions Packages

- Enterprise Editions Packages

- Professional Editions Package's

- RetailDemo Editions Packages

 

Personal Untrusted Security and Private Data Leaks, for me and the most Users: (means I don't trust you, Microsoft, to keep my Private Data Private !!!) - This doesnt meant, that some parts of it cant be usefull, if they are End-To-End Encrypted with SHA-512 or better...:

- BioEnrollment

- Biometrics

- Calendar

- Cloud

- Contacts

- Cortana

- Defender

- FaceAnalysis

- Photos

- Geolocation

- Grove Music

- Movie & TV

- OneDrive

- Telemetry

- RemoteAssistance & RemoteDesktop

- ShareMedia

- Sway

- WMPNetworkSharingService

 

Sense and Useless:

- 3D Builder (sadly I don't have a 3D Printer)

- Candy Crush (Don't need it)

- Finance (no Broker here)

- First Steps... (your and My One, are in different reality's)

- Handwriting (no Touchscreen or similar thing here)

- IIS (this is a single HomePC no Network, no Webserver !)

- Indexer (On a SSD [Limited Write Cycles !!!] its doing useless writings - build a better Searchoption like XP Search or Agent Ransack instead)

- Mail (no I don't use offline mails at all, cause Windows 10 is starving to often, and I don't like to lost or need rescue them every time !)

- Maps (OK not such bad thing, but I have Google Maps !)

- Minecraft (don't need it !)

- News ( I like to choose Media I trust by myself, thx !)

- ntv (I don't trust them - the Sending to much unreflective uncritical documentations about Weapons and Tanks - its like the TV from the Starship Troopers Movie... !)

- OCR (Never used it since Win95)

- Office Downloader (sorry, I decide years ago to use OpenOffice !)

- OfflineFiles (my Files are always OFFLINE !)

- OneNote (don't need it !)

- ParentalControls (there are no Kids inside here !)

- Photoshop Express (Photoshop CS2 is Freeware until 2 Years and much better !)

- Prefetch & Co (its still an SSD I use, stop limiting its lifetime by unneeded writings !)

- Printing Online (would never ever do that)

- Skype (no Skype at all, but if - I use the Portable Version !)

- SnippingTool (useless, I am able to push the Printscreen Button on my Keyboard, and add and edit it in Paint by myself !)

- SNMP-Package (I only need IPV4 and maybe IPV6 in the future ! Nothing else ! No IGMP, no LLDP, no QOS, no Topology, no Multiplex... - its a Single PC without Network !)

- Solitare (don't need it !)

- Speech (don't need it !)

- SpeechComponents (I am not blind)

- Spelling-Dictionaries (I prefer the Build-in Language Correction of a Writing Software)

- Sport (I hate all that violent National Fan Racists of popular Sports so much, that I hate Sportnews by itself !)

- StickyNotes (I use notepad and the desktop instead !)

- StorageService (don't need it !)

- Synchronization (to often I just named files with different contends the same name, and I don't like to destroy my data by hitting a button)

- TabletPC (no Tablet here !)

- Telephone Stuff (no, I don't have a LuminaPhone, and I don't want it !)

- TextPrediction (don't need it)

- TextToSpeech (maybe I could keep that, if it works a 100% in German)

- Twitter (no I don't use it, and if, I use it in Browser only !)

- UAC (I Prefer a Sandbox, a Outbound Firewall, Regshot, and the netstat Command for untrusted Software instead !)

- WebcamExperience (what Kind of Experience you talking about ? Don't need it)

- Windows Hello (my PC don't have any Intelligence by itself - maybe in 500 years... So stop saying hello to me !)

- WinSATMediaFiles (senseless, 3D Mark, Prime95 and SpecViewPerf are the Standard Benchmark Tools)

- XBox (I DON'T HAVE ONE !)

- Xps (Never used that..)

 

10) Bug: Repair Installation dont works

I did a unsuccessful repair installation after I broke the system by trying to remove the above Packages with dismn Online command, so I was forced to do a new Full Install...

 

 

Thx for Reading

R4D3

 

 

P.S. - Cause english isnt my native language, i used a online Spellchecker before, - if something is to hard to understand, cause of some language mistakes, just tell me...

Edited by R4D3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Great topic :D

 

after trying to make windows 10 lite as i like

i conclude that i need server

 

Now I'm running server 2008 r2

come with nothing installed by default

explorer handles around 530 / win7 - 900 / win10 - 1500

 

very basic OS that works great, server 2016 will be the same model

 

Microsoft forgot big community of power users, that don't need those useless components

Edited by aviv00

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2) BUG: Standard Scheduled Tasks destroys Power Saving !
One ore more of the preconfigurated Tasks (why there are so many of them - its like a Overkill) destroys Energy Saving modes like Standby !
That means: My Laptop start Up from Sleep by itself and do things (I don't know) by itself...
 
LISTEN Microsoft: IF I SEND MY LAPTOP TO SLEEP, IT HAS TO SLEEP, NOT TO WAKEUP AND DO STUFF I DON'T KNOW, BY ITSELF ! (If I decide to add a Schedulerjob, it would run in Idle-Mode, before Standby !)

 

Don't even dare put a sleeping laptop in a case where air can't circulate!

 

But that's just silly, right?  Who'd ever want to put a laptop into a case?  (I'm being sarcastic)

 

Microsoft has made running Windows only about running Windows.  It no longer matters to them whether we do anything else.

 

Yes, there are WAYYY too many scheduled tasks.  They're just hanging stuff all over Windows 10 without a care about whether the system is efficient.  It looks like junior application programmers have taken over system design at Microsoft, leaving (I guess) middle school students to program the Apps.

 

I'm developing a Re-Tweaker script to re-do many of the settings I choose to change, Apps I choose to remove, services and scheduled jobs I choose to disable - and which get put back by each in-place upgrade on 4 month intervals.  It's just ridiculous to have to do all this stuff.

 

-Noel

Edited by NoelC
  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 Who'd ever want to put a laptop into a case?

 

 

You know, i allready thought, that a good system would not let you shutdown a full heatet system without a warning message, and would do a full cpu/gpu cooldown before shutdown - on this way many laptops would be protected from micro cracks, and get a longer lifetime cyle... - but thats another case...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was more worrying about it coming on automatically while in a case, where no air could circulate and cool it.

 

I've heard of it happening, causing meltdowns.

 

-Noel

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

- i just wrote, how it should be instead... ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...